Topic: Liberal Fascism
Of the many contradictions in progressive practice, none is more striking than the defense of Islam.
It must be admitted, I think, that as a rule progressivism is allergic to religion. The latter, with its stress on faith, received wisdom, traditional morality, etc. is naturally offensive to proponents of progress who believe that humanity is the measure of all things. So on any number of issues—abortion, same-sex marriage, sexual morality—progressives and religious believers find themselves at odds. Hence the ongoing progressive effort to push religion out of the public square.
Quite often this effort is accompanied by the most crude and offensive expressions of bigotry, e.g. the anti-religious diatribes of Bill Maher. It so happens that a good number of progressives are atheists of a particularly obnoxious strain: the kind of atheists who, as George Orwell put it, don’t merely disbelieve in God but bear him a personal grudge. Radical feminists, for instance, are always going on about religious patriarchy, supposedly a mechanism for the oppression of women. And of course if one takes a long historical view of the matter the feminists have something of a point. Times have changed, however, and there are vanishingly few believing Christians around today who regard women as second-class citizens or chattel.
But it so happens that there’s one real, existing religious patriarchy that does regard women as second-class citizens or chattel and treats them as such: Islam. A good case can be made that the number-one human rights issue in the world today is the oppression of women and that a leading (though not the sole) offender in that regard is Islam. Female genital mutilation, forced marriages, honor killings, flogging and execution for sexual immorality, denial of education and legal rights—the list of abuses is long and infamous. Nor can it be said that Islam’s attitude toward homosexuality is particularly enlightened. Finally, Islam’s claim to temporal as well as spiritual authority directly challenges the progressive principle that religion has no place in public life.
Yet when Bill Maher—give him credit for being consistent—uttered some inconvenient truths about the nature of Islam he was roundly condemned as an “Islamophobe” by progressives who’d nodded along with his hateful anti-Christian rants. Maher’s observations about Islam, which though offensively phrased were factual enough, sent these people into a three-foot hover.
You can see why. Islam isn’t a Christian family, offending progressives by joining hands and saying grace in a restaurant. It’s not a Catholic speaking out against abortion. It’s not an evangelical Christian church refusing to conduct a same-sex wedding ceremony. Islam, in the eyes of progressives, is the faraway Third World, oppressed by Western capitalism, imperialism, colonialism, etc., etc.
Here again progressive have a point—historically. Much of the Islamic world has experienced the heavy hand of Western domination, either directly or indirectly. For a culture with a proud imperial past, the decline in Islam’s fortunes that set in around 1800 was painful indeed. Islam went from ruling a large chunk of Europe to being ruled by European countries. The collapse of the Ottoman Empire at the end of the Great War completed this shameful turnabout. Carving knives in hand, the victorious European powers gathered around the Ottoman carcass. To some extent, therefore, the condition of the Islamic world today is the legacy of European imperialism.
And here we come to the contradiction. The narrative of the oppression of women by a religiously sanctioned patriarchy is one theme of progressivism. The narrative of the oppression of Third World peoples by Western imperialists is another theme of progressivism. Islam is the point at which these narratives intersect—and something had to give. Thus it is that the same people who wring their hands over the (largely phony) issues of equal pay for women and the rape culture close their eyes, plug their ears and cry “Bigot!” when Islam’s long list of crimes against women is flourished. Think about that the next time you hear some nosebleed feminist fulminating about the patriarchy.